The Hidden Cost of Digital Tithing

How Physical Giving Builds Faith in Our Children

The shift to digital giving—whether through electronic transfers, online platforms, or automatic payments—has been accelerated by recent global events and offers undeniable convenience for churches. While this transition may simplify financial administration, it has significant implications for discipleship, particularly among children and young people. Passing a collection plate was never just a way to raise funds; it was a profound moment of teaching, participation, and embodiment of faith. Here are some reasons why removing this physical practice may unintentionally hinder our ability to disciple the next generation effectively.

A Missed Opportunity to Teach Generosity

One of the simplest ways to teach children about generosity is by allowing them to witness and participate in a physical collection. Watching the collection plate passed from person to person—and seeing parents and other adults contribute—creates a powerful, visual lesson in giving. Through this act of worship, children see firsthand that generosity and stewardship are fundamental expressions of faith. As Paul writes in 2 Corinthians 9:7, “God loves a cheerful giver,” reminding us that giving is a joy-filled response to God’s grace.

While digital giving may be effective for adults, it lacks the same visual impact. For children, generosity risks becoming an abstract concept rather than a tangible experience. Without the opportunity to observe or participate, they may miss the lesson that supporting the church and helping others is central to Christian worship. A physical collection integrates giving into worship, teaching that faith is not solely about receiving but also about giving in response to God’s blessings. Through these simple, visible acts, children come to understand that worship is a wholehearted response to all that God has provided.

Loss of a Participatory Worship Experience

The physical collection serves as a concrete, participatory act of worship. For children, worship can sometimes feel abstract or passive, especially when much of the service is word-based. But placing something in a collection basket is a direct, tangible way to contribute, making worship accessible even to the youngest members. The simple action of dropping a coin into a plate fosters a sense of belonging and involvement, reinforcing that worship is a shared, communal act. Physical acts of giving help them experience worship as a lived response, showing that worship includes practical acts of love and service.

Risk of Reinforcing a Consumer Mindset

In a culture saturated with consumerism, a physical collection offers a powerful counter-message. It teaches children that church is not simply a place to receive but a community where everyone has an active role. By contributing—even in small ways—children start to understand that they are part of something larger than themselves, a family of believers who serve, support, and sacrifice for one another.

Without this participatory moment, children may more easily adopt a consumer mindset, viewing church as a service provider designed to meet their preferences rather than a shared mission. Without the physical act of giving, the sense of community contribution may be reduced to an individualised experience, potentially reinforcing a “consumer” view of church rather than a shared mission.

Building the Habit of Giving

Habits shaped early in life often stay with us, and cultivating generosity in childhood can lay a foundation for lifelong stewardship. When children participate in giving—even if it’s simply placing a coin or small offering into a collection plate—they begin to see generosity as a regular, joyful part of worship. This visible, consistent practice nurtures the belief that every aspect of life—including our financial decisions—can be an offering to God, cultivating a spirit of generosity that is likely to endure throughout their lives.

Modelling Faithful Behaviour in a Visible Way

Children learn by example. When they see adults around them contributing during a physical collection, it is a powerful form of discipleship. This visible act of giving teaches them that supporting the church, helping the needy, and being generous are normal and joyful parts of Christian life. Parents, in particular, have the opportunity to model faithful behaviour, showing that they, too, contribute to the mission of the church.

With digital-only giving, children miss this example and may not realise that their church community is made up of individuals who each contribute to its life and work. When we remove the visibility of giving, we lose a chance to disciple our children in understanding the responsibility and joy of supporting the church.

Rooted in Tradition: The Ecclesiological Significance of the Physical Collection

The shift from visible giving departs from a long-standing tradition in church history, where financial offerings were seen as integral to worship and unity. A physical collection reaches back to early Christian practices, where giving was a tangible expression of worship and communal responsibility. In the New Testament, believers gathered contributions not only to support the church but also to care for the needy, demonstrating their unity in Christ (Acts 4:34-35, 1 Corinthians 16:1-2).

Thomas Cranmer, architect of the Book of Common Prayer, included the offertory as a means of responding to God’s grace through practical stewardship. For Cranmer and many reformers, worship was both personal and communal, involving the full participation of each believer.

By moving away from a visible offering, we risk shifting from collective worship to private convenience. While digital giving is practical, it can diminish giving as an expression of unity and shared mission. Church history reminds us that the physical act of giving in worship shapes our understanding of community, generosity, and faithful response to God’s provision.

Returning to a Whole-Life Worship

If we want to nurture generosity, stewardship, and community responsibility in our young people, perhaps we should consider reintroducing some form of visible giving. This could involve rethinking how we approach giving in our services, creating opportunities for families to talk with their children about generosity, or finding new ways to connect children’s financial stewardship with their faith. While digital giving has undeniable advantages, there is something invaluable about visibly including children in the act of giving.

Growing Young Disciples has a threefold mandate: to train, resource, and advise…

Meet the team…

6–9 January 2025.

Yarnfield Park.

Conference 2025

This year, our theme is ‘Christ: Prophet, Priest, and King’. We will use the traditional categories of Jesus as prophet, priest, and king to enhance our understanding of his life, death, burial, resurrection, and ascension. Be prepared to be blown away by the majesty and beauty of the Lord Jesus!

Seminary level training in children’s, youth and family ministry.

Find out more

All content © Growing Young Disciples 2024.

Subscribe to the blog